Preserving the One-Frame Feel of Combat Even in the AI Era

Team NINJA: "A Difficult Game and an Unfair Game Are Different"

Korean (한국어) Add us on
와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
©INVEN

At GCON 2026 on November 19, Producers Kohei Shibata and Masakazu Hirayama of Koei Tecmo Games' Team NINJA presented the development philosophy behind the 'Nioh' and 'Wo Long' series. While both franchises feature high difficulty, their combat directions are quite distinct. Whereas 'Nioh' emphasizes the static focus and instantaneous strikes of a samurai, 'Wo Long' focuses on the fluid, aggressive offense and defense characteristic of Chinese martial arts.

In a joint media interview following the presentation, the producers went into further detail, touching on the background behind these differences, the exchange of development experiences between the franchises, and how they incorporate global player feedback. Regarding AI technology, a hot topic in game development recently, they stated that while they already utilize AI for quality assurance and verification tasks, human judgment remains essential in perfecting the fun of action gameplay.

The two producers also explained their criteria for distinguishing between high-difficulty games and unfair games. The key lies in whether players can learn an attack and test ways to counter it. No matter how powerful an attack is, if players have no means to react, it can hardly be considered a fair battle.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
From left: Team NINJA Producer Masakazu Hirayama, Producer Kohei Shibata ©INVEN

First, we would like to hear your thoughts on visiting Korea and participating as speakers at GCON. What message did you hope to share with Korean developers and gamers through this presentation?

Masakazu Hirayama: I have long known that Korea is a vibrant market for online games, and recently I've heard that console gaming has also been growing significantly active here. We wanted to share with Korean developers and players the mindset with which we create our games. I hope we can advance the entire game industry together by sharing our experiences with one another.

Kohei Shibata: This was my first time visiting G-STAR. I looked around the venue, and the energy on-site was immensely impressive. I participated in this presentation hoping to convey the appeal of our games and the action RPG genre to as many people as possible.

Both 'Nioh' and 'Wo Long' are high-difficulty action RPGs created by Team NINJA, yet the actual feel of combat is quite different. How would you define the action of each series in a single phrase?

Kohei Shibata: I consider 'Nioh' to be samurai action. Samurai combat involves stillness and movement. You stand firmly grounded, observing the opponent's moves, and deliver a sharp strike the instant an opening appears. Instead of constantly moving while attacking, you watch the enemy from a static position and strike in a split second. Engaging in a life-or-death gamble on that fleeting opening is what samurai action is all about, and that's the direction we pursued from when we first started making 'Nioh.'

Masakazu Hirayama: To sum up 'Wo Long' in one phrase, it would be 'aggressive Chinese martial arts action.' While 'Nioh' focuses on stillness and movement, our starting point was contemplating what defines Chinese martial arts. In Chinese martial arts movies, attack and defense flow together seamlessly. The exchange of strikes is fast and intense, yet the movement itself is graceful. We wanted to capture that impression in the game. That's why we introduced systems like Spirit and Deflect. Aggressively attacking is important, but defense must also lead directly into the next attack. We designed it consistently so that both offense and defense create proactive combat.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
Wo Long and Nioh feature distinct styles of action ©INVEN

As developers creating different series within the same studio, were there elements from each other's games that you felt envious of or wanted to reference?

Kohei Shibata: Although addressed to some extent in 'Nioh 3,' the previous 'Nioh' games did not feature a jump. Pursuing samurai action made it difficult to fully implement acrobatic movements. On the other hand, 'Wo Long' utilized jumps to deliver much more multi-dimensional and dynamic action. I envied that aspect and referenced it heavily when implementing new movement mechanics in 'Nioh 3.'

Masakazu Hirayama: I had many thoughts watching Team NINJA develop open-world and open-field environments through 'Rise of the Ronin' and 'Nioh 3.' When creating the first 'Wo Long,' we used a linear mission structure, which limited our ability to express strategic freedom. The stage sizes themselves were constrained, making it difficult to fully showcase the vast battlefields characteristic of the Three Kingdoms. Watching other teams build open fields made me wonder, "What if we built Wo Long with a structure like this?" That became a major catalyst for planning 'Wo Long 2.'

There was another point I envied. While 'Nioh' is set in Japan, 'Wo Long' is set in China. When developing the first game, researching materials on Chinese history was extremely challenging. Although we worked with Chinese staff members to research local literature and visual materials during development, gathering such vast data was not easy, especially when starting the project with a small team. In that regard, I envied the 'Nioh' team for working with their own country's history.

Since both of you toured G-STAR in person, did you notice any unique characteristics of G-STAR compared to Tokyo Game Show or other overseas gaming events?

Kohei Shibata: First of all, I felt the event venue design was fantastic. The overall visual design—including the venue layout and logo—was very sophisticated. To put it simply, I got the impression that it was truly "cool."

Masakazu Hirayama: I was particularly impressed by the passion felt at the booths of game companies from Korea and other Asian countries. Even compared to Tokyo Game Show, there was a remarkably strong energy. Touring various booths gave me a lot of vitality. As a developer, it was a very inspiring experience.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
The presentation by the two producers drew high popularity ©INVEN

Both 'Nioh' and 'Wo Long' receive feedback from players around the world. How do you collect feedback by region, and what are your criteria for implementing it into actual development?

Masakazu Hirayama: We collect information online much more actively than players might think. In Japan, we check X, and overseas, we check platforms mainly used in each region, such as Reddit or Chinese social media. We carry out this work almost every day. One of the most important ways we gather feedback is through demo versions. Recently, Team NINJA titles often provide demos before their official release. We release these globally and analyze regional reactions and feedback trends.

Based on those results, we decide which areas to improve before the official launch. This approach has established itself as an essential part of Team NINJA's game refinement process in recent years.

Kohei Shibata: In player feedback, there are areas that don't differ much by country, and areas where differences appear. Evaluations regarding the fundamental fun of the game, such as action or level design, surprisingly show little difference. Players in Japan, Korea, other Asian countries, and Western regions are quite similar in what they find enjoyable or frustrating, though individual preferences vary, of course. On the other hand, there are differences in the level of familiarity with historical backgrounds. 'Nioh' uses Japanese history and 'Wo Long' uses Chinese history. It's easy for developers to assume players know who a character is just by hearing their name.

However, many Western players may not be familiar with those specific historical figures or events. We realized that historical knowledge developers take for granted isn't something every player possesses. Therefore, we pay extra attention to ensuring that players unfamiliar with the history can still understand the characters' traits and enjoy the story.

Both series have evolved in different directions, and modern action games are increasingly combining various genres and systems. From your perspective as long-time action game developers, what is the core essence that must be preserved regardless of any changes?

Kohei Shibata: I believe it's control responsiveness. When a player presses a button, the character must move exactly as they intended. If you press a button and the character doesn't react properly, it causes frustration. Conversely, if a slight input causes an exaggerated movement, it feels awkward. Therefore, responsiveness to input must be simple and intuitive, and the movement must be communicated rapidly. That sense of the game accurately responding when a player inputs something is the core of action games.

Masakazu Hirayama: Fundamentally, I feel the same way. However, I think the reason action feels different in each title comes down to their distinct themes. Players expect different movements depending on whether it's samurai action or Chinese martial arts action. The development team strives to translate the movements and sensations people naturally associate with a theme into actual gameplay. Those differences give each game's action its own distinct personality. Yet at the foundation lies the intuitiveness and responsiveness of controls that Producer Shibata mentioned. That is something Team NINJA universally values.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
Both producers cited "responsiveness" as the most vital element in action games ©INVEN

'Nioh 3' and 'Wo Long 2' attempt a transition from traditional linear mission structures to open fields. What are the pros and cons of both structures, and why did you choose open fields over further expanding the existing approach?

Masakazu Hirayama: The biggest advantage of linear level design is that you can pack a dense experience into a single stage. You can concentrate enemy placement, exploration routes, and combat tension within a dedicated space. On the other hand, because you move to the next stage upon completing one, the continuity of the player experience can feel lacking. While open fields resolve this issue, there's also the risk of diluting the dense action experience previously provided. I heard that the 'Nioh 3' team also faced challenges implementing that balance.

We also considered that issue crucial. Instead of simply connecting spaces to make them larger, we strived to preserve in open fields the dense experience previously offered by linear stages.

Kohei Shibata: With the 'Nioh' series, I believed each sequel had to evolve beyond its predecessor. In 'Nioh 3,' we added the ninja combat style, significantly altering both the visual appearance and feel of the action. Naturally, we felt the stage and level design needed to evolve as well. Rather than merely refining existing stage designs, we judged that fundamentally altering the layout would transform the player experience. Thus, we boldly introduced open fields.

Team NINJA already possessed experience developing an open world with 'Rise of the Ronin.' We also believed combining that know-how with the level design experience accumulated from 'Nioh' would yield exciting results.

Masakazu Hirayama: For 'Wo Long,' we felt the Three Kingdoms theme itself fit open fields exceptionally well. The conflicts of the Three Kingdoms involve events unfolding across multiple locations toward a single conclusion, with various characters' stories influencing one another. In that setting, we wanted to craft an experience where players make choices and alter the war situation in their own way. We determined that open fields were ideal for delivering the sensation of directly reshaping the flow of historical warfare. That was a key reason for choosing a new structure in 'Wo Long 2.'

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
A story taking place after the Battle of Red Cliffs, reimagined completely anew ©INVEN

'Nioh 3' achieved strong sales performance right from its launch. How do you evaluate player feedback so far, and was there any opinion from Korean players that particularly stood out?

Kohei Shibata: As I mentioned earlier, feedback regarding the action gameplay itself didn't differ much between Japan and Korea. Reactions regarding what felt fun or what was difficult to grasp were generally similar. Rather than unique opinions specific to Korean players standing out, there was a lot of shared feedback. However, since the game draws from Japanese history, figures or events that Japanese players naturally understand may not be familiar to overseas players. We are continually learning how to convey those elements so anyone can understand them.

'Wo Long 2' is set in the Three Kingdoms era, where historical events and figures are already established. How did you balance reproducing historical facts with offering players freedom in their experience?

Masakazu Hirayama: I actually consider that an advantage of creating historical works. While historical events and figures are set, there are many details not recorded in depth in actual history. I find a sense of historical romance in those gaps. For example, even if a figure appears in history, what they thought or did at a specific moment might be unrecorded. I believe there is considerable freedom in depicting those moments through the development team's interpretation.

There is also fun for players in researching actual history after playing the game. Studying historical events might lead them to realize, "Ah, that's why they portrayed it that way in the game based on this record." Being able to enjoy both the game and history together is the charm of history-based games.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
Wo Long was built on ideas generated during the development of a new IP ©INVEN

Ahead of its launch next year, 'Wo Long 2' provided a hands-on demo opportunity at this year's G-STAR. Did observing Korean players' gameplay yield any useful insights for development?

Masakazu Hirayama: It was wonderful to have demo stations set up this time. Of course, we watch videos and streams of players playing the game. However, opportunities to observe players controlling the game right before our eyes on-site are rare. Today as well, I stood continuously behind players watching them play. From the players' perspective, having someone watch from behind all the time might have been a bit overwhelming. (Laughs) Still, we gained a tremendous amount of information. We could directly see where players struggled and how they approached cleared challenges.

It was extremely helpful in identifying areas to refine before the official launch. I am very glad we were able to observe actual gameplay at G-STAR.

As game development technology advances rapidly, the creation environment is also changing. How is Team NINJA embracing these changes, and what development methods will remain unchanged regardless of technological progress?

Masakazu Hirayama: CG technology and hardware performance continue to advance even now. Team NINJA is also steadily carrying out technology development so as not to fall behind those changes. As game engines and various tools evolve, the development process becomes increasingly convenient. However, no matter how technology progresses, I believe there is work that will always persist: the fine-tuning of action. Even now, individual staff members adjust character movements frame by frame, down to 1 or 2 frames. A difference of just a few frames can change the intuitive feel of controls for players.

No matter how technology evolves, I believe the work of perfecting the tactile feel of action through such adjustments will continue.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
Preserving the "tactile feel of action" through fine adjustments remains a critical priority ©INVEN

Recently, AI technology has also emerged as a major topic in game development. How is Team NINJA actually utilizing AI, and what is your view on its future possibilities?

Kohei Shibata: Currently, we utilize AI in QA and various verification tasks to streamline certain workflows. If we can use AI to shorten task times, we can dedicate that saved time toward elevating the game's overall quality. In that sense, using AI is beneficial. However, since it is still a new technology, we are continuously evaluating the most appropriate ways to implement it. I imagine other game companies are facing similar questions.

What matters fundamentally is that a game becomes fun when crafted by human hands. Repetitive, simple tasks that anyone must perform can be streamlined using technology. But ultimately, deciding how to craft the game and what makes it enjoyable must be done by humans. Using AI itself should never become the goal. I believe the principle that humans must think for themselves and finish the game will remain unchanged in the future.

In today's presentation as well, you emphasized fairness in high-difficulty action games. What is the boundary between a "difficult game" and an "unfair game" in the eyes of the development team? When a boss receives feedback for being too difficult, how do you decide whether to lower the difficulty or improve it so players accept it while maintaining the original difficulty?

Kohei Shibata: What Team NINJA values is fairness between enemy and player. We aim to prevent players from feeling something is unfair. If an enemy uses an immensely powerful attack, the player must also have actions available to counter it. What matters is whether the player can learn and understand the enemy's attack, then determine how to react. For instance, even if you know an attack is coming, if you get hit without even time to press a button, that's an unfair situation. We try to eliminate such elements during development.

Another important aspect is providing players with opportunities to learn attacks. In high-difficulty action games, taking a hit from an enemy and retrying based on that experience is the core loop. For example, suppose a boss possesses an exceptionally powerful attack. If getting hit for the first time results in instant death, the player gets no chance to test what they've learned within that battle. On the other hand, what if getting hit for the first time takes away about 80% of their health? It clearly conveys that it's a very dangerous attack, yet leaves the player with an opportunity to observe the next attack and test counter strategies.

Rather than simply raising or lowering damage values, it is crucial to ensure players can learn enemy behavior and apply their understanding in actual combat. Whether that process is possible is what I believe separates a difficult game from an unfair game.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
Team NINJA games developed under the same philosophy ©INVEN

Recently in the gaming market, live-service games and premium packaged games are competing in different ways for players' time. What do you consider the unique competitive edge of packaged games?

Kohei Shibata: I think live-service games basically need to be enjoyable over a long period—in a sense, endlessly. Though it might sound a bit negative, live-service games are structured so they shouldn't end easily. New content must keep appearing, allowing players to enjoy them over a prolonged period. Of course, that model has clear advantages and appeal. In contrast, packaged games have a definitive end. Because of that, you can build up the narrative toward that conclusion and deliver an intense climax at the end.

I like to compare that difference to a multi-season TV show versus a standalone film. A series can stretch a story across multiple seasons, whereas a film creates narrative highs and lows within a limited runtime to deliver an emotional peak at the end. Packaged games are similar. Within a set play experience, they can alternate tension and relief, ultimately delivering emotion or excitement at the finish line. Naturally, games enjoyed long-term like multi-season series have their own distinct charm. However, delivering intense emotion through a single, complete experience is a key competitive advantage for packaged games.

Finally, do you have any words for the Korean fans who have long cherished Team NINJA's works?

Masakazu Hirayama: To everyone in Korea, thank you so much for always playing our games. Visiting Korea for the first time, I was deeply moved by the love for gaming and the passion at the event. We will continue to make games you can enjoy. 'Wo Long 2: Wings of Ember' is also set to launch in the near future, so we ask for your interest and support. We look forward to your continued support.

Kohei Shibata: I also visited Korea for the first time through this G-STAR. In fact, I wanted to visit Korea when 'Nioh 3' was released, but couldn't due to schedule conflicts. I'm truly thrilled to finally be here. I was grateful to meet members of the media and players enjoying our games in person, and to see so many people attend our presentation. It was all the more meaningful because we rarely get opportunities to meet fans directly like this.

We will continue to pay attention to the Korean market and strive to bring you great games. News regarding the second DLC for 'Nioh 3' is also scheduled to be revealed soon, so please look forward to future announcements. Thank you.

와룡2 Wo Long2: Wings of Ember
©INVEN
Originally written in Korean, this article was translated with AI assistance and edited by a native English-speaking editor. Every translation is reviewed by our editorial team before publication. [Read Original]