Annapurna, known for consistently delivering impressive indie games with compelling narratives, has once again drawn significant critical acclaim with this new title from Beethoven & Dinosaur.
💯* Score Roundup - We track and organize scores and reviews from major international outlets for your convenience. For both games and movies, we prioritize top-tier critics to provide a clear, at-a-glance summary.
Beethoven & Dinosaur previously earned praise for The Artful Escape, a psychedelic musical platformer inspired by David Bowie and Ziggy Stardust. While some felt the game was a bit short, it was widely lauded for the unique experience created by its music and gameplay.
Mixtape takes that foundation further with even more distinct visuals and a deeper narrative. The story, which follows a group of youths through a single night while leaning heavily into 80s and 90s nostalgia, is being praised for its direction, which evokes the style of Sony’s Spider-Man animated films. Furthermore, critics have noted that the music integration—a strength of the developer's previous work—feels even more impactful here thanks to the use of licensed tracks.
The story pushes the emotional resonance typical of indie games to the limit, emphasizing the shared experience of that era over major conflict. As with the developer's previous title, the short length and gentle pacing are cited as drawbacks. Some reviewers also noted that those who did not personally experience the 80s and 90s may find it difficult to relate to certain aspects of the game.
Nevertheless, Mixtape has established itself as one of the most impressive narrative-driven indie games of the first half of the year, holding a 85 on Metacritic (based on the most-reviewed PS5 version) and a 91 on OpenCritic.
Mixtape
Beethoven & Dinosaur · PC/PS5/XSX/Switch 2 · 2026.05.07
Metacritic
Metascore 22 Reviews · PS5
OpenCritic
MIGHTY
Top Critic Avg 20 Reviews · 100% Recommended
👍 Pros
+80s-90s licensed music that fits every scene perfectly
+A sincere coming-of-age story depicting friendship, parting, and rites of passage
+Heart-tugging moments and emotionally resonant expressions
+Original art direction and visuals reminiscent of stop-motion
+Witty script and natural, impressive voice acting
+Diverse and creative mini-games that appear in every scene
👎 Cons
−A safe, plain story lacking any real core conflict
−Short length of about 4 hours with almost no replay value
−Simple, repetitive gameplay involving walking around rooms and clicking on objects
−A sense of distance for those who cannot relate to 80s-90s nostalgia
Metascore by Platform
PC
93
14 Reviews
PS5
85
22 Reviews
Switch 2
88
5 Reviews
Xbox
tbd
3 Reviews
🟢 Metacritic - Key Reviews
100
IGN PS5
A joy from start to finish, fueled by music. With its masterful sense of style, it sets a new standard for coming-of-age video games.
100
VGC PS5
A tribute to the 'brightest days of our lives.' It captures an unadorned nostalgia for youth and offers a witty insight that life doesn't end just because it isn't a Hollywood-style 'last night.' The use of music is flawless, elevating Mixtape to one of the best modern coming-of-age games.
100
DualShockers PS5
A coming-of-age story that hits every note perfectly. A witty, laugh-out-loud script, stellar voice acting, gorgeous art direction, and endlessly creative gameplay blend with a flawless soundtrack. It is a gaming experience like no other, filled with nostalgia, humor, and heart-tugging moments.
100
CGMagazine PC
A 'greatest hits' collection spanning gameplay, story, music, and animation. It is a true work of art that you would be remiss not to experience.
100
Stevivor PC
A game that feels like a warm hug. It offers a nostalgic look at an era that older generations like us now call the 'simpler times.' It is a blend of grunge and punk sensibilities, hope and foolishness, cool and nerdiness, confidence and anxiety.
90
GameSpot PC
Rather than a game with a good soundtrack, it is more like an interactive experiment where the soundtrack itself is the core. If it had been made as a film, it would never have been this impactful. The music drives everything to the very end.
90
Game Informer PC
Even for someone like me who loves coming-of-age stories, Mixtape stands out. It nails the sincere yet quirky tone and treats life's rites of passage with heavy authenticity. With its brilliant script, lean length, and clever use of the soundtrack, it completes a nostalgic journey that will instantly become a classic.
90
Nintendo Life Switch 2
Mixtape's greatest achievement is that it exceeds the expectations set by its name. Before it is a carefully curated album, it is an exciting, emotional, and funny game. It doesn't just have you mindlessly clicking while licensed music plays; it makes you live life alongside the soundtrack.
90
Push Square PS5
Stunning set pieces, gorgeous visual design, and an intense soundtrack. All of these combine to make Mixtape a rare, meaningful story-driven game. It is beautiful to look at, a joy to listen to, and above all, fun to play. In a word, it is a magnificent achievement.
90
Shacknews PC
When the end credits rolled, I was sad it was over so soon. Then I realized it’s a game I’ll inevitably return to. Just like the coming-of-age films that inspired it and the timeless artists on its soundtrack, I will find myself coming back to Mixtape again and again.
90
PlayStation LifeStyle PS5
One of the most beautiful visuals on the PS5, paired with a thrilling, nostalgia-filled soundtrack. Mixtape is a meaningful coming-of-age story that is a joy to play through to the end. The trophy list, which encourages the use of chapter select, provides a reason to return without padding the main game.
80
TheGamer PS5
Despite its limited gameplay and somewhat repetitive structure of walking around rooms and clicking on objects, Mixtape is an experience that will stay with you for a long time. Sharp dialogue that sounds authentic without being grating, comfortable storytelling, a great soundtrack, and a confident attitude toward the medium make it a work well worth listening to.
80
GamesRadar+ PS5
An atmospheric, nostalgic piece that leans on a surprisingly solid soundtrack. The music is not only narratively important but also great to listen to on its own. It is a short, meaningful game that carries the lethargy of the teenage years without ever feeling oppressive. However, the game mechanics are relatively light.
80
IGN Deutschland PC
A one-of-a-kind adventure that pulls you deep into the complex emotional world of teenagers. It is occasionally ridiculous and exaggerated, but it also has many sincere and nostalgia-inducing moments. Much of this is thanks to the fantastic 80s soundtrack. However, the depth of the gameplay remains a bit disappointing due to how quickly it ends.
60
Guardian PS5
This Mixtape took the safe route. It is a crowd-pleasing compilation filled with teenage clichés and tributes to coming-of-age films. While it features a series of beautiful and whimsically ridiculous musical vignettes, it lacks a real core conflict and doesn't quite reach the impressive heights of Life is Strange.
This article was originally written in Korean and translated with the help of NC AI. It was then edited by a native English-speaking editor. All AI-assisted translations are reviewed and refined by our newsroom.
[Read Original]
